Study Finds Revised Mammography Guidelines May Have Impacted Drop in Screenings

March 29, 2023 by Kate Strotmeyer

UVM Cancer Center researchers Sarah Nowak, Ph.D., and Brian Sprague, Ph.D., found that a 2009 U.S. Preventive Services Task Force change in guidelines led to an unintended consequence: a decline in mammography screening rates for all age groups, including the 50-74 group, which is most at risk of developing breast cancer and most in need of screenings. Their results were recently published in The American Journal of Preventative Medicine.

Mammograms are X-ray pictures of the breast and are effective in detecting early signs of breast cancer. New UVM research shows a decline in screenings for the most at-risk group after guidelines were revised. (Getty Images)

Since 2009, Vermont had second largest decline in at-risk screenings of any state

In 2009, the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force changed its mammography screening guidelines to recommend that routine breast cancer screening start at age 50 rather than age 40, recommending an individualized approach for women ages 40-49. The group cited insufficient evidence for screening women ages 75 and older.

University of Vermont (UVM) Cancer Center researchers Sarah Nowak, Ph.D., and Brian Sprague, Ph.D., found that the change in guidelines led to a decline in mammography screening rates for all three age groups, including in the 50-74 group most at risk of developing breast cancer and most in need of screenings, an unintended consequence. The researchers coined the the term "spillover" for this effect since the new guidelines were intended to reduce unnecessary screening for groups less at risk but spilled over to at-risk women. Vermont had the second steepest drop of any state for all three groups. 

Their results were recently published in The American Journal of Preventative Medicine

Data from 2002 through 2018 illustrates that, after 2009, screening rates have fallen nationally by 1.3 percentage points per year for ages 40-49, .5 percentage points per year for women aged 50-74 years old, and 1.7 percentage points per year for 75+

In Vermont, these numbers nearly doubled: 2.5 percentage points for 40-49, 1.2 percentage points for 50-74, and 2.9 percentage points for 75+.

“While these percentages may seem small, the cumulative impact over 10 years translates to 2.4 million fewer women in the United States aged 50-74 being up to date with screening mammography,” said Sprague, who is a professor of surgery at the UVM's Larner College of Medicine. The number of Vermont women age 50-74 affected over the 10-year period is approximately 10,000 people.

The research team is currently exploring why spillover is happening. For example, evidence shows that when women know someone personally diagnosed with breast cancer through screening, they encourage others to get screened. Declining screening for women ages 40-49 and 75+ could lead to women ages 50-74 learning about early-stage breast cancer diagnoses in friends and family less often.

“It is especially important to understand why rates of screening are declining for women ages 50-74 in Vermont. Understanding what is happening locally can help us understand what may be happening in the rest of the country in future years,” said Nowak, who is an assistant professor of pathology and laboratory medicine at UVM's Larner College of Medicine. 


We foster brilliant teachers, who educate talented students, who become the caring, knowledgeable physicians and scientists of tomorrow.


 

Voices of the College

 

smiling student in graduation garb holding school staff

“Working in the ED, I came to see a very clear picture of my future and resolved to become a physician that embodied the values I saw there.”

— Elise Prehoda, Class of 2024

Read the blog post by three 2024 Larner graduates


Larner Volunteers at the 2024 Vermont City Marathon

Information about Match Day 2024

View the Marathon Slideshow


Events


Popular Links

Larner celebrates bicentennial

Innovation in Medical Education for More Than 200 Years